{
  "arguments": [
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "id": "arg-actors-not-transmitters",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "kind": "isnad",
      "limitations": "لا حكم على مجموع مرويات كل شخصية ولا نفي لسماع في طريق آخر لم يحقق هنا.",
      "riwayaRefs": [],
      "scope": "sample",
      "statement": "سهل ومعاوية وقبيصة وأبو مسلم شخصيات في المتون المعروضة؛ لا يجعلها الرسم شيوخاً لمن حكى أفعالها بلا تصريح بالسماع. النص يسمي قبيصة العبسي الرواحي دون اسم أبيه.",
      "targets": []
    },
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "id": "arg-book-attribution",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "kind": "isnad",
      "limitations": "HOLD_ABU_MUSLIM_ROUTE_RECONCILIATION: أي نسبة بديلة للمصنفح37825 تحتاج إسنادها وموضعها؛ لا تُستعار أسماء طريق لتقوية آخر.",
      "riwayaRefs": [],
      "scope": "sample",
      "statement": "فرع أبي مسلم هنا من كتاب يحيى الجعفي كما نقله الذهبي، لا من صفوان عن أبي مسلم في المصنف. حاشية السير تقول رجاله ثقات؛ اتصال الخبر وخلاف حال يحيى باقيان للفحص.",
      "targets": [
        "yahya_jufi"
      ]
    },
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-shammari-shura-112-113"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-shammari-shura-112-113"
      ],
      "id": "arg-shura-nasr-debt",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "kind": "isnad",
      "limitations": "HOLD_NASR_IBN_MUZAHIM_KITAB: مقابلة نص وقعة صفينص75–87 وطرقه غير مقفلة. الشورى والمكاتبات سياق معلن خارج عد فروع الرسم؛ لم تحذف من ملف التحقيق.",
      "riwayaRefs": [],
      "scope": "sample",
      "statement": "بطاقة الشورى تحفظ طريق صالح الشديد الضعف المنقطع ومرسل الزهري؛ وتصحيح الشمري للمجموع بالشواهد لا يصل أحدهما. مكاتبات نصر ليست سماعاً مباشراً من معاوية، فلا يرسم بينهما سهم نقل.",
      "targets": []
    },
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "id": "arg-accountability-limit",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "kind": "matn",
      "limitations": "ثبوت الموضع الرقمي غير ثبوت الواقعة؛ مسؤولية كل قائد وفعله تحتاج دليلهما المستقل.",
      "riwayaRefs": [],
      "scope": "sample",
      "statement": "العدد ووصف الجمهور ونفي علي أصوات داخل خبر ضعيف، لا إحصاء ولا براءة قضائية. وفي فرع أبي مسلم تبقى وأحق بالأمر مني في اللفظ؛ المطالبة بالقصاص لا تصحح كل وسيلة سياسية.",
      "targets": []
    }
  ],
  "citations": [
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": {
        "bookId": 6877,
        "pageId": 2332,
        "provider": "shamela"
      },
      "id": "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "فمما كتب إلي السري، عن شعيب، عن سيف، عن محمد وطلحة، قالا: بعث علي عماله على الأمصار",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "الطبري، تحقيق محمد أبو الفضل إبراهيم، دار المعارف،ج4ص442–443؛ الشاملة6877ص2332–2333"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "مقابلة النص الرقمي المحلي فقط؛ أصل الطبعة المصور والتحقيق الإسنادي مستقلان.",
      "quote": "فمما كتب إلي السري، عن شعيب، عن سيف، عن محمد وطلحة، قالا: بعث علي عماله على الأمصار",
      "sourceId": "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya",
      "sourceRef": "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "discovery_only",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": {
        "bookId": 6877,
        "pageId": 2334,
        "provider": "shamela"
      },
      "id": "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "دعا معاوية برجل من بني عبس، ثم أحد بني رواحة يدعى قبيصة، فدفع إليه طوماراً مختوماً",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "الطبري،ج4ص444؛ الشاملة6877ص2334، ضمن سياق الطريق المبدوء فيص442"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "مقابلة النص الرقمي المحلي فقط؛ أصل الطبعة المصور والتحقيق الإسنادي مستقلان.",
      "quote": "دعا معاوية برجل من بني عبس، ثم أحد بني رواحة يدعى قبيصة، فدفع إليه طوماراً مختوماً",
      "sourceId": "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya",
      "sourceRef": "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "discovery_only",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": {
        "bookId": 598,
        "pageId": 2946,
        "provider": "shamela"
      },
      "id": "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "ثم قال الجعفي: حدثنا يعلى بن عبيد، عن أبيه، قال: جاء أبو مسلم الخولاني وأناس إلى معاوية",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "الذهبي،سير أعلام النبلاء،مؤسسة الرسالة،ج3ص140؛ الشاملة598ص2946"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "مقابلة النص الرقمي المحلي فقط؛ أصل الطبعة المصور والتحقيق الإسنادي مستقلان.",
      "quote": "ثم قال الجعفي: حدثنا يعلى بن عبيد، عن أبيه، قال: جاء أبو مسلم الخولاني وأناس إلى معاوية",
      "sourceId": "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi",
      "sourceRef": "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "discovery_only",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": "تلخيص حكم باحث معاصر بحسب السجل والبطاقة المرتبطين؛ لم تعاد مقابلة الصورتين في هذه الجولة",
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": null,
      "id": "cit-shammari-shura-112-113",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "صحيح بشواهده",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "فواز الشمري،صحيح أخبار صفين والنهروان وعام الجماعة،ج1ص204–205،ح112–113"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "إحالة سياقية إلى دراسة المجموع؛ لا توثق سماعاً من صاحب الواقعة ولا تصل مرسل الزهري ولا طريق صالح.",
      "quote": "صحيح بشواهده",
      "sourceId": "source-sahih-akhbar-siffin-shammari-shura-qisas",
      "sourceRef": "source-sahih-akhbar-siffin-shammari-shura-qisas",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "unverified",
      "verificationLimits": null
    }
  ],
  "dependencyHash": "a12b2e9d8de81553",
  "diagnostics": {
    "errors": [],
    "warnings": [
      "evidenceStatus=incomplete: 32/32 hotspots تحتاج تعيين المصدر والموضع"
    ]
  },
  "evidenceStatus": "incomplete",
  "illal": [],
  "interactionIndex": {
    "hotspots": {
      "argument:arg-accountability-limit": {
        "argumentRefs": [
          "arg-accountability-limit"
        ],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة",
          "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "العدد ووصف الجمهور ونفي علي أصوات داخل خبر ضعيف، لا إحصاء ولا براءة قضائية. وفي فرع أبي مسلم تبقى وأحق بالأمر مني في اللفظ؛ المطالبة بالقصاص لا تصحح كل وسيلة سياسية. — ثبوت الموضع الرقمي غير ثبوت الواقعة؛ مسؤولية كل قائد وفعله تحتاج دليلهما المستقل."
        },
        "id": "argument:arg-accountability-limit",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "argument",
        "label": "العدد ووصف الجمهور ونفي علي أصوات داخل خبر ضعيف، لا إحصاء ولا براءة قضائية. وفي فرع أبي مسلم تبقى وأحق بالأمر مني في اللفظ؛ المطالبة بالقصاص لا تصحح كل وسيلة سياسية.",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya",
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "argumentId": "arg-accountability-limit"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "argument:arg-actors-not-transmitters": {
        "argumentRefs": [
          "arg-actors-not-transmitters"
        ],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة",
          "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "سهل ومعاوية وقبيصة وأبو مسلم شخصيات في المتون المعروضة؛ لا يجعلها الرسم شيوخاً لمن حكى أفعالها بلا تصريح بالسماع. النص يسمي قبيصة العبسي الرواحي دون اسم أبيه. — لا حكم على مجموع مرويات كل شخصية ولا نفي لسماع في طريق آخر لم يحقق هنا."
        },
        "id": "argument:arg-actors-not-transmitters",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "argument",
        "label": "سهل ومعاوية وقبيصة وأبو مسلم شخصيات في المتون المعروضة؛ لا يجعلها الرسم شيوخاً لمن حكى أفعالها بلا تصريح بالسماع. النص يسمي قبيصة العبسي الرواحي دون اسم أبيه.",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444",
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya",
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "argumentId": "arg-actors-not-transmitters"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "argument:arg-book-attribution": {
        "argumentRefs": [
          "arg-book-attribution"
        ],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة",
          "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "فرع أبي مسلم هنا من كتاب يحيى الجعفي كما نقله الذهبي، لا من صفوان عن أبي مسلم في المصنف. حاشية السير تقول رجاله ثقات؛ اتصال الخبر وخلاف حال يحيى باقيان للفحص. — HOLD_ABU_MUSLIM_ROUTE_RECONCILIATION: أي نسبة بديلة للمصنفح37825 تحتاج إسنادها وموضعها؛ لا تُستعار أسماء طريق لتقوية آخر."
        },
        "id": "argument:arg-book-attribution",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "argument",
        "label": "فرع أبي مسلم هنا من كتاب يحيى الجعفي كما نقله الذهبي، لا من صفوان عن أبي مسلم في المصنف. حاشية السير تقول رجاله ثقات؛ اتصال الخبر وخلاف حال يحيى باقيان للفحص.",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "argumentId": "arg-book-attribution"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "argument:arg-shura-nasr-debt": {
        "argumentRefs": [
          "arg-shura-nasr-debt"
        ],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-shammari-shura-112-113"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-shammari-shura-112-113"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة",
          "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "بطاقة الشورى تحفظ طريق صالح الشديد الضعف المنقطع ومرسل الزهري؛ وتصحيح الشمري للمجموع بالشواهد لا يصل أحدهما. مكاتبات نصر ليست سماعاً مباشراً من معاوية، فلا يرسم بينهما سهم نقل. — HOLD_NASR_IBN_MUZAHIM_KITAB: مقابلة نص وقعة صفينص75–87 وطرقه غير مقفلة. الشورى والمكاتبات سياق معلن خارج عد فروع الرسم؛ لم تحذف من ملف التحقيق."
        },
        "id": "argument:arg-shura-nasr-debt",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "argument",
        "label": "بطاقة الشورى تحفظ طريق صالح الشديد الضعف المنقطع ومرسل الزهري؛ وتصحيح الشمري للمجموع بالشواهد لا يصل أحدهما. مكاتبات نصر ليست سماعاً مباشراً من معاوية، فلا يرسم بينهما سهم نقل.",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-shammari-shura-112-113"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-sahih-akhbar-siffin-shammari-shura-qisas"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "argumentId": "arg-shura-nasr-debt"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:muhammad": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "محمد، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:muhammad",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "محمد، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "muhammad"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:sari": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "السري: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:sari",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "السري: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "sari"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:sayf": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "سيف بن عمر: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:sayf",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "سيف بن عمر: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "sayf"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:shuaib": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "شعيب: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:shuaib",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "شعيب: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "shuaib"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:talha": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "طلحة، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:talha",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "طلحة، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "talha"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:ubayd": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "والد يعلى بن عبيد: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:ubayd",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "والد يعلى بن عبيد: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "ubayd"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:yala": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "يعلى بن عبيد: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:yala",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "يعلى بن عبيد: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "yala"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-muhammad-sayf": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "عن"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-muhammad-sayf",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "عن",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-sahl-radd",
          "matn-tumar-qabisa"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-tabari-muhammad"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-muhammad-sayf",
          "from": "muhammad",
          "to": "sayf"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-sari-tabari": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "كتب إليّ"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-sari-tabari",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "كتب إليّ",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-sahl-radd",
          "matn-tumar-qabisa"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
          "riwaya-tabari-talha"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-sari-tabari",
          "from": "sari",
          "to": "tabari"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-sayf-shuaib": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "عن"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-sayf-shuaib",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "عن",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-sahl-radd",
          "matn-tumar-qabisa"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
          "riwaya-tabari-talha"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-sayf-shuaib",
          "from": "sayf",
          "to": "shuaib"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-shuaib-sari": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "عن"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-shuaib-sari",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "عن",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-sahl-radd",
          "matn-tumar-qabisa"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
          "riwaya-tabari-talha"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-shuaib-sari",
          "from": "shuaib",
          "to": "sari"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-talha-sayf": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "عن"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-talha-sayf",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "عن",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-sahl-radd",
          "matn-tumar-qabisa"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-tabari-talha"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-talha-sayf",
          "from": "talha",
          "to": "sayf"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-ubayd-yala": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "عن"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-ubayd-yala",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "عن",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-abu-muslim"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-jufi-abu-muslim"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-ubayd-yala",
          "from": "ubayd",
          "to": "yala"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-yala-yahya_jufi": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "حدثنا"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-yala-yahya_jufi",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "حدثنا",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-abu-muslim"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-jufi-abu-muslim"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-yala-yahya_jufi",
          "from": "yala",
          "to": "yahya_jufi"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "hukm:sayf": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حكم الراوي",
          "meaning": "الحكم المنسوب إلى ناقد؛ لا يدل لون الأيقونة على رتبة الراوي",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "سيف بن عمر: ضعيف"
        },
        "id": "hukm:sayf",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "hukm",
        "label": "سيف بن عمر: ضعيف",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "hukm",
          "nodeId": "sayf"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "matn:matn-abu-muslim": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن",
          "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "لا والله، إني لأعلم أنه أفضل مني، وأحق بالأمر مني، ولكن ألستم تعلمون أن عثمان قتل مظلوماً، وأنا ابن عمه، والطالب بدمه، فائتوه، فقولوا له، فليدفع إلي قتلة عثمان، وأسلم له ... فأتوا علياً، فكلموه، فلم يدفعهم إليه"
        },
        "id": "matn:matn-abu-muslim",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "matn",
        "label": "الفرع المنقول عن الجعفي؛ لا حذف لعبارة الأحقية",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-abu-muslim"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-jufi-abu-muslim"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "matnId": "matn-abu-muslim"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "matn:matn-sahl-radd": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن",
          "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "وأما سهل فإنه خرج حتى إذا كان بتبوك لقيته خيل، فقالوا: من أنت؟ قال: أمير، قالوا: على أي شيء؟ قال: على الشام، قالوا: إن كان عثمان بعثك فحيهلا بك، وإن كان بعثك غيره فارجع!"
        },
        "id": "matn:matn-sahl-radd",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "matn",
        "label": "بعثة سهل ورده في سياق خبر سيف",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-sahl-radd"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
          "riwaya-tabari-talha"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "matnId": "matn-sahl-radd"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "matn:matn-tumar-qabisa": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن",
          "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "ففض خاتمه فلم يجد في جوفه كتابة ... وتركت ستين ألف شيخ يبكي تحت قميص عثمان ... اللهم إني أبرأ إليك من دم عثمان"
        },
        "id": "matn:matn-tumar-qabisa",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "matn",
        "label": "الطومار: كلام الرسول ونفي علي داخل الحكاية",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-tumar-qabisa"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
          "riwaya-tabari-talha"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "matnId": "matn-tumar-qabisa"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:muhammad": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "محمد، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع — هكذا سُمّي في الطريق؛ لم تُقفل هويته ولا اتصاله بالواقعة"
        },
        "id": "node:muhammad",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "محمد، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "muhammad"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:sari": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "السري — كتب إلى الطبري؛ لا تثبت هنا زيادة النسب أو الرتبة"
        },
        "id": "node:sari",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "السري",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "sari"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:sayf": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "سيف بن عمر — مدار خبر رد سهل والطومار؛ ضعيف في حكم الفصل"
        },
        "id": "node:sayf",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "سيف بن عمر",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "sayf"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:shuaib": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "شعيب — عن سيف في إسناد الطبري؛ باقي بياناته تحتاج دليلاً حقلياً"
        },
        "id": "node:shuaib",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "شعيب",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "shuaib"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:tabari": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "تاريخ الطبري — خبر تفريق العمال والطومار،ج4ص442–444"
        },
        "id": "node:tabari",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "تاريخ الطبري",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "tabari"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:talha": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "طلحة، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع — مقرون بمحمد؛ اقترانهما ليس طريقين مستقلين عن مدار سيف"
        },
        "id": "node:talha",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "طلحة، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "talha"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:ubayd": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "والد يعلى بن عبيد — والد يعلى، يحكي وفد أبي مسلم؛ لا تصريح بالسماع من أبي مسلم في النص"
        },
        "id": "node:ubayd",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "والد يعلى بن عبيد",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "ubayd"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:yahya_jufi": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "صفين ليحيى بن سليمان الجعفي — قال: حدثنا يعلى؛ ينقل الذهبي من كتابه، لا سماع مباشر منه"
        },
        "id": "node:yahya_jufi",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "صفين ليحيى بن سليمان الجعفي",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "yahya_jufi"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:yala": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "needs_review",
          "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً",
          "summary": "يعلى بن عبيد — يروي عن أبيه؛ هذه سلسلة الجعفي المنقولة في السير"
        },
        "id": "node:yala",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "يعلى بن عبيد",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "map_scope",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "yala"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "verdict": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "خلاصة الدراسة",
          "meaning": "النتيجة المنسوبة إلى الدراسة وحدود الاستدلال",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "خبر سيف ضعيف كما في الفصل؛ وفرع أبي مسلم يحتاج فحص الاتصال والاختلاف الرجالي. ثبوت النصوص في المصنفات لا يثبت جميع المشاهد ولا يحكم بالبراءة أو الإدانة."
        },
        "id": "verdict",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "verdict",
        "label": "خبر سيف ضعيف كما في الفصل؛ وفرع أبي مسلم يحتاج فحص الاتصال والاختلاف الرجالي. ثبوت النصوص في المصنفات لا يثبت جميع المشاهد ولا يحكم بالبراءة أو الإدانة.",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "verdict"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      }
    },
    "order": [
      "node:muhammad",
      "city:muhammad",
      "node:talha",
      "city:talha",
      "node:sayf",
      "hukm:sayf",
      "city:sayf",
      "node:shuaib",
      "city:shuaib",
      "node:sari",
      "city:sari",
      "node:tabari",
      "node:ubayd",
      "city:ubayd",
      "node:yala",
      "city:yala",
      "node:yahya_jufi",
      "edge:edge-muhammad-sayf",
      "edge:edge-sayf-shuaib",
      "edge:edge-shuaib-sari",
      "edge:edge-sari-tabari",
      "edge:edge-talha-sayf",
      "edge:edge-ubayd-yala",
      "edge:edge-yala-yahya_jufi",
      "matn:matn-sahl-radd",
      "matn:matn-tumar-qabisa",
      "matn:matn-abu-muslim",
      "verdict",
      "argument:arg-actors-not-transmitters",
      "argument:arg-book-attribution",
      "argument:arg-shura-nasr-debt",
      "argument:arg-accountability-limit"
    ]
  },
  "map": {
    "chapter": "02_manuscript/bab_08_al_mawsuaa_al_hadithiyya/18_athar_radd_sahl_wa_tumar_muawiya_wa_murasalat_siffin.md",
    "dependencyHash": "a12b2e9d8de81553",
    "id": "athar_radd_sahl_wa_tumar",
    "ref": "isnad:athar_radd_sahl_wa_tumar@v4",
    "sourceFile": "08_assets/isnad/athar_radd_sahl_wa_tumar.json",
    "sourceHash": "bc6420b677323df3",
    "version": 4
  },
  "matnVariants": [
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
      ],
      "id": "matn-sahl-radd",
      "label": "بعثة سهل ورده في سياق خبر سيف",
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
        "riwaya-tabari-talha"
      ],
      "role": "context",
      "subject": null,
      "text": "وأما سهل فإنه خرج حتى إذا كان بتبوك لقيته خيل، فقالوا: من أنت؟ قال: أمير، قالوا: على أي شيء؟ قال: على الشام، قالوا: إن كان عثمان بعثك فحيهلا بك، وإن كان بعثك غيره فارجع!"
    },
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "id": "matn-tumar-qabisa",
      "label": "الطومار: كلام الرسول ونفي علي داخل الحكاية",
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
        "riwaya-tabari-talha"
      ],
      "role": "context",
      "subject": null,
      "text": "ففض خاتمه فلم يجد في جوفه كتابة ... وتركت ستين ألف شيخ يبكي تحت قميص عثمان ... اللهم إني أبرأ إليك من دم عثمان"
    },
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "id": "matn-abu-muslim",
      "label": "الفرع المنقول عن الجعفي؛ لا حذف لعبارة الأحقية",
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-jufi-abu-muslim"
      ],
      "role": "context",
      "subject": null,
      "text": "لا والله، إني لأعلم أنه أفضل مني، وأحق بالأمر مني، ولكن ألستم تعلمون أن عثمان قتل مظلوماً، وأنا ابن عمه، والطالب بدمه، فائتوه، فقولوا له، فليدفع إلي قتلة عثمان، وأسلم له ... فأتوا علياً، فكلموه، فلم يدفعهم إليه"
    }
  ],
  "narrators": [
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 3,
        "exactFields": 0,
        "status": "unresolved",
        "unresolvedFields": 3
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "identity": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
          ],
          "state": "incomplete",
          "supportLevel": "map_scope",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "muhammad",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "محمد، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع",
      "sub": "هكذا سُمّي في الطريق؛ لم تُقفل هويته ولا اتصاله بالواقعة"
    },
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 3,
        "exactFields": 0,
        "status": "unresolved",
        "unresolvedFields": 3
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "identity": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
          ],
          "state": "incomplete",
          "supportLevel": "map_scope",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "talha",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "طلحة، شيخ سيف في هذا الموضع",
      "sub": "مقرون بمحمد؛ اقترانهما ليس طريقين مستقلين عن مدار سيف"
    },
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 4,
        "exactFields": 0,
        "status": "unresolved",
        "unresolvedFields": 4
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "identity": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
          ],
          "state": "incomplete",
          "supportLevel": "map_scope",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": "daif",
      "id": "sayf",
      "kind": "madar",
      "label": "سيف بن عمر",
      "sub": "مدار خبر رد سهل والطومار؛ ضعيف في حكم الفصل"
    },
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 3,
        "exactFields": 0,
        "status": "unresolved",
        "unresolvedFields": 3
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "identity": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
          ],
          "state": "incomplete",
          "supportLevel": "map_scope",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "shuaib",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "شعيب",
      "sub": "عن سيف في إسناد الطبري؛ باقي بياناته تحتاج دليلاً حقلياً"
    },
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 3,
        "exactFields": 0,
        "status": "unresolved",
        "unresolvedFields": 3
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "identity": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
          ],
          "state": "incomplete",
          "supportLevel": "map_scope",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "sari",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "السري",
      "sub": "كتب إلى الطبري؛ لا تثبت هنا زيادة النسب أو الرتبة"
    },
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 3,
        "exactFields": 0,
        "status": "unresolved",
        "unresolvedFields": 3
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "identity": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
          ],
          "state": "incomplete",
          "supportLevel": "map_scope",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "ubayd",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "والد يعلى بن عبيد",
      "sub": "والد يعلى، يحكي وفد أبي مسلم؛ لا تصريح بالسماع من أبي مسلم في النص"
    },
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 3,
        "exactFields": 0,
        "status": "unresolved",
        "unresolvedFields": 3
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "identity": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
          ],
          "state": "incomplete",
          "supportLevel": "map_scope",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "yala",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "يعلى بن عبيد",
      "sub": "يروي عن أبيه؛ هذه سلسلة الجعفي المنقولة في السير"
    }
  ],
  "pipelineVersion": 7,
  "provenanceCoverage": {
    "arguments": 4,
    "citations": 4,
    "dependencyHash": "a12b2e9d8de81553",
    "exactHotspots": 0,
    "illal": 0,
    "matnVariants": 3,
    "missingCards": [],
    "missingSources": [],
    "narrators": 7,
    "percentExact": 0,
    "riwayat": 3,
    "status": "incomplete",
    "totalHotspots": 32,
    "transmissions": 7,
    "unresolvedHotspots": 32
  },
  "provenanceStatus": "draft",
  "provenanceVersion": 2,
  "records": {
    "cards": [
      {
        "contentHash": "2844bdd38a8a361c",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "evidence-ibn-khaldun-muqaddimah-267-ijma-lahiq-wa-sardiyat-qabisa",
        "path": "05_cards/evidences/ibn-khaldun-muqaddimah-267-ijma-lahiq-wa-sardiyat-qabisa.md",
        "status": "verified_with_limits",
        "title": "ابن خلدون وقبيصة: خبرٌ عن الدم ورأيٌ في الانعقاد"
      },
      {
        "contentHash": "f1971f3d5c052afa",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "evidence-muawiya-shura-qisas-uthman-zuhri-salih-kaysan",
        "path": "05_cards/evidences/muawiya-shura-qisas-uthman-zuhri-salih-kaysan.md",
        "status": "verified_with_limits",
        "title": "الشورى والطلب بدم عثمان: برنامج تعبئة محفوظ بأخبار متفاوتة"
      },
      {
        "contentHash": "2801f9049b63c5e3",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "evidence-abu-muslim-muawiya-afdaliyat-ali-yahya-al-jufi",
        "path": "05_cards/evidences/abu-muslim-muawiya-afdaliyat-ali-yahya-al-jufi.md",
        "status": "verified_with_limits",
        "title": "خبر أبي مسلم: فرع الجعفي وألفاظه وحدود الاحتجاج به"
      }
    ],
    "sources": [
      {
        "author": "محمد بن جرير الطبري",
        "authorDeathHijri": "310",
        "contentHash": "a303898c2e9f6685",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya",
        "path": "04_source_bank/source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya.md",
        "status": "draft",
        "title": "تاريخ الرسل والملوك — قرارات علي الإدارية والسياسية"
      },
      {
        "author": "محمد بن أحمد الذهبي",
        "authorDeathHijri": "748",
        "contentHash": "b8d62deb388ffe8a",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi",
        "path": "04_source_bank/source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi.md",
        "status": "draft",
        "title": "سير أعلام النبلاء — خبر أبي مسلم الخولاني مع معاوية"
      },
      {
        "author": "فواز بن فرحان بن راضي الشمري",
        "authorDeathHijri": null,
        "contentHash": "b0f028210751fa72",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "source-sahih-akhbar-siffin-shammari-shura-qisas",
        "path": "04_source_bank/source_sahih_akhbar_siffin_shammari_shura_qisas.md",
        "status": "verified_with_limits",
        "title": "صحيح أخبار صفين والنهروان وعام الجماعة"
      }
    ]
  },
  "riwayat": [
    {
      "chain": [
        "muhammad",
        "sayf",
        "shuaib",
        "sari",
        "tabari"
      ],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "familyId": "family-tabari-sayf-muhammad-talha",
      "hukmCitationRefs": [],
      "hukmEvidenceRefs": [],
      "id": "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "label": "محمد وطلحة مقرونان في خبر واحد عند سيف؛ فرع رسم لا شاهد مستقل",
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-sahl-radd",
        "matn-tumar-qabisa"
      ],
      "nodePath": [
        "muhammad",
        "sayf",
        "shuaib",
        "sari",
        "tabari"
      ]
    },
    {
      "chain": [
        "talha",
        "sayf",
        "shuaib",
        "sari",
        "tabari"
      ],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "familyId": "family-tabari-sayf-muhammad-talha",
      "hukmCitationRefs": [],
      "hukmEvidenceRefs": [],
      "id": "riwaya-tabari-talha",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "label": "محمد وطلحة مقرونان في خبر واحد عند سيف؛ فرع رسم لا شاهد مستقل",
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-sahl-radd",
        "matn-tumar-qabisa"
      ],
      "nodePath": [
        "talha",
        "sayf",
        "shuaib",
        "sari",
        "tabari"
      ]
    },
    {
      "chain": [
        "ubayd",
        "yala",
        "yahya_jufi"
      ],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "familyId": "family-jufi-yala-father",
      "hukmCitationRefs": [],
      "hukmEvidenceRefs": [],
      "id": "riwaya-jufi-abu-muslim",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "label": "يحيى الجعفي عن يعلى عن أبيه؛ النقل عن الكتاب عند الذهبي",
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-abu-muslim"
      ],
      "nodePath": [
        "ubayd",
        "yala",
        "yahya_jufi"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "schemaVersion": 2,
  "transmissions": [
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "from": "muhammad",
      "id": "edge-muhammad-sayf",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-sahl-radd",
        "matn-tumar-qabisa"
      ],
      "note": "عن",
      "requiresPinpoint": true,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-tabari-muhammad"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "map_scope",
      "to": "sayf",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "from": "sayf",
      "id": "edge-sayf-shuaib",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-sahl-radd",
        "matn-tumar-qabisa"
      ],
      "note": "عن",
      "requiresPinpoint": true,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
        "riwaya-tabari-talha"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
      ],
      "status": "weak",
      "supportLevel": "map_scope",
      "to": "shuaib",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "from": "shuaib",
      "id": "edge-shuaib-sari",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-sahl-radd",
        "matn-tumar-qabisa"
      ],
      "note": "عن",
      "requiresPinpoint": true,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
        "riwaya-tabari-talha"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "map_scope",
      "to": "sari",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "from": "sari",
      "id": "edge-sari-tabari",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-sahl-radd",
        "matn-tumar-qabisa"
      ],
      "note": "كتب إليّ",
      "requiresPinpoint": true,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-tabari-muhammad",
        "riwaya-tabari-talha"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "map_scope",
      "to": "tabari",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-tabari-sahl-442"
        ]
      },
      "from": "talha",
      "id": "edge-talha-sayf",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-sahl-radd",
        "matn-tumar-qabisa"
      ],
      "note": "عن",
      "requiresPinpoint": true,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-tabari-sahl-442",
        "cit-tabari-tumar-444"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-tabari-talha"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-tarikh-al-tabari-qararat-ali-al-idariyya-wa-al-siyasiyya"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "map_scope",
      "to": "sayf",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ]
      },
      "from": "ubayd",
      "id": "edge-ubayd-yala",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-abu-muslim"
      ],
      "note": "عن",
      "requiresPinpoint": true,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-jufi-abu-muslim"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "map_scope",
      "to": "yala",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
        ]
      },
      "from": "yala",
      "id": "edge-yala-yahya_jufi",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-abu-muslim"
      ],
      "note": "حدثنا",
      "requiresPinpoint": true,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-siyar-abu-muslim-140"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-jufi-abu-muslim"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-siyar-abu-muslim-yahya-al-jufi"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "map_scope",
      "to": "yahya_jufi",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    }
  ]
}